10 Best Mascot Horror Games on PlayStation 5 2025

Mascot horror games feature characters who evoke a lot of nostalgia from our childhood days. Except rather than bring warmth and joy, they are now portrayed as terrifying villains out to get you. Coupled with a spooky environment and vibe, mascot horror games become this unique sub-genre of indie gaming that finds a clever way to capitalize on both happiness and absolute terror. 

It’s become a staple for many gamers of all ages, among them the best mascot horror games on PlayStation 5 below. 

10. Choo-Choo Charles

Trains shouldn’t do the things that Charles does, but here we are. Choo-Choo Charles goes a step further in gameplay than most mascot horror games do. It has a massive open area filled with railway tracks to navigate. You’re controlling a train yourself, an old, clunky one at that, and winding down complex paths. 

Depending on which route you choose, you just might come face to face with bloodthirsty Charles, or meet townspeople who help you out with weapons and other resources. You can upgrade your train, too, by looting, all in preparation for the ultimate Charles takedown.

9. Freddy Fazbear’s Pizzeria Simulator

Five Nights at Freddy’s has been diversifying its location to other odd jobs, like running a pizzeria. In Freddy Fazbear’s Pizzeria Simulator,  you’re simply making pizzas for kids and earning high scores for the best ones. But soon, FNaF’s signature starts to creep in through the attractions you purchase, encompassing the franchise’s vengeful animatronics. 

And by nightfall, when you close your business, the animatronics come out to play. They crawl through the air vents, but a quick flick of your flashlight should scare them away, among other survival tools at your disposal. This isn’t your everyday job pizza job, apparently.

8. Amanda the Adventurer

The story of Amanda the Adventurer is told via old VHS tapes you find in your aunt’s attic. Probably best left untouched, but now that you’ve watched a couple of episodes, there’s no turning back. Amanda, harkening back to Dora the Explorer, and her buddy, Wooly the Sheep, start to talk to you, and not very kindly. They lead you down a twisted path full of secrets and mysteries you can’t help chasing down.

7. My Friendly Neighborhood

My Friendly Neighborhood used to be an old kids’ puppet show. After years of its studios getting shut down, the servers suddenly sprang back up and are running. And you, as the repairman, are the unfortunate guy to get sent to investigate.

Not knowing what you’ll find in the abandoned production studio fuels your curiosity, as you delve deeper into the unknown. And things get even more strange when the puppets from the show turn out to be alive, and not very friendly at all. 

6. Finding Frankie

Finding Frankie, meanwhile, is the perfect mascot horror game for those looking to spice up their chases. Instead of just running fast, you actually consider the layout of the environment as well. It’s designed as a challenging parkour course with trippy, neon-bright colors that can easily disorient you. 

Blood pulsing through your veins, a menacing monster hot on your tail, Finding Frankie turns out to be especially satisfying for adrenaline junkies. Everything from wall jumps to rail grinds and grappling hooking around is a given as you scamper around the environments to save your life.

5. Circus of TimTim

Why ever would two siblings decide to sneak into the most haunted carnival of all time is beyond me. Anyway, they, of course, run into trouble in the next of the best mascot horror games on PlayStation 5 called Circus of TimTim. With your detective hat put on, you’ll use stealth to sneak around the ruins of the once-friendly family circus. You’ll explore every nook and cranny, finding items that help you survive the enemies and TimTim, roaming around the place.

4. Garten of Banban

As for Garten of Banban, it takes place in, uhm, you guessed it, kindergarten. But suddenly, everyone at the school vanished. Now, it’s up to you and your trusty drone to investigate. Banban and Friends, the mascots initially entertaining at the school, definitely have something to do with it; you’re just going to have to find out what exactly. 

3. Poppy Playtime

At the Playtime Co. toy factory, the halls and walls echo with silence. At least until the vengeful toys initially produced here spring up, menacing in their new appearance, and looking to strip you of your life. Poppy Playtime is among the best mascot horror games on PlayStation 5 you’ll ever play. It’s mystery-ridden story is engrossing, and its survival mechanics are frantic enough to induce panic. 

Moreover, the PlayStation version comes with patch updates, including better graphics, gameplay, and additional bug fixes.

2. Bendy and the Ink Machine

Think black and white Mickey Mouse, but dashed in creepy yellow and black paint. Bendy and the Ink Machine is a first-person mascot horror game harkening back to the taste and style of old childhood cartoons. However, it tells no innocent tale, featuring Henry’s visit back to the demons of his past. 

Throughout the abandoned animator’s workshop, you’ll discover numerous dark twists and turns. Thrilling around every corner, despite how scary some scenes and revelations can be. Still, this is one of the most unique mascot horror games out there, with an immersive atmosphere that you’ll be thinking about, nightlight turned on. 

1. Five Nights at Freddy’s

In first place is Five Nights at Freddy’s, which, to this day, still seems to have fresh, new, engaging ways of play. Despite being trapped in a small office, it still remains engaging, fumbling around the security cameras to watch out for the killer animatronics on the loose. You’re manning the security doors but also scrambling around in the dark. Vents are also a way through for the animatronics. 

Paying close attention to the monitors is your saving grace, but also your senses. Is that a screech you hear in the distance? Are those footsteps creeping close?