If you loved the shadows and secrets of This Bed We Made, you're probably on the hunt for more mystery games that pull you into their world just as deeply. That's the special thing about a great mystery game: it wraps you up in a story that's thick with intrigue and sprinkled with clues, keeping you hooked until the very end. So, we've gathered a list of the five best mystery games like This Bed We Made, each one ready to offer its own brand of mystery and storytelling that will keep you guessing and engaged.
Oxenfree invites players into a world where an ordinary teen trip to an island turns into a spooky adventure. The story starts simply enough: Alex and her buddies head to Edwards Island for some fun. But they find more than they bargained for on this old island, which is full of strange secrets and echoes of its past. As you play, the island feels almost alive, offering puzzles and mysteries that unfold effortlessly, pulling you deeper into its ghostly tale. And playing Oxenfree is interactive storytelling at its best. But you're not just watching a story happen; you're a part of it, walking around the island, poking around in abandoned buildings, and solving the puzzles that come your way.
However, what really makes Oxenfree unique among the best mystery games like This Bed We Made is how real the characters talk to each other. They chat, argue, and joke just like real people, and you get to choose what Alex says in these conversations. Your choices can change the story, making you think hard about what to say next. This makes your adventure personal; the friendships in the game can change based on what you decide, just like in real life. Also, the sound of the game is especially cool, with a synth music score that feels like it's straight out of the '80s.
4. What Remains of Edith Finch
When you play What Remains of Edith Finch, you're walking into a house filled with stories. You play as Edith, the last of the Finch family, and as you explore each room in their big, strange house, it's like opening a book full of family tales. The game doesn't just stick to one style. One minute you might be reading a comic book, and the next, you're in a spooky story or playing as a cat. It's this mix that makes the game so special, where figuring out what happened is a big part of the fun.
Furthermore, the house in the game is a weird place with secret passages and locked doors. It's almost like the house itself is telling you its secrets. As you move from room to room, you find out about each family member's life and, sometimes, how they died. These aren't just regular stories, either. They're full of imagination and can be pretty wild—like a little kid dreaming of being a monster or a man who thinks he's a king. This game doesn't just give you all the answers. Instead, you get pieces of stories that make you think and feel a lot. Sometimes they're happy, sometimes sad, and they often end in a way that surprises you and sticks in your mind.
3. The Vanishing of Ethan Carter
The Vanishing of Ethan Carter takes players into a world filled with secrets and a touch of the supernatural. In this game, you play as a detective with special abilities named Paul Prospero. You're on a mission to find out what happened to a boy named Ethan Carter. Unlike the tight spaces of the Clarington Hotel in This Bed We Made, this game spreads out before you in a vast, open area just waiting for you to explore. It doesn’t just tell you where to go or what to look for; it lets you find your own way and figure things out for yourself, which feels really rewarding.
Additionally, the way you interact with this game is special. You come across scenes that look like something bad happened there, and it’s your job to piece together the story from the clues you find. It's like putting together a jigsaw puzzle that makes a picture of what occurred. In addition, the game does a fantastic job of making you feel connected to this world and its mysteries. In short, it’s the kind of game that stays with you, haunting you with its beauty and the sad stories it tells, long after you’ve finished playing.
2. Gone Home
In Gone Home, you find yourself at the doorstep of an empty house that feels like it's hiding a thousand stories. With each room you enter, there's a clue waiting to be discovered. The game takes you on a quiet adventure where the smallest details—a scribbled note, a ticket stub, a faded photo, tell a family's tale. It's like a puzzle where every piece is hidden in plain sight, and finding them doesn't just mean looking under beds or behind doors, but really seeing into the lives of the people who lived there.
Moreover, the stories you uncover are about ordinary things that mean a lot: growing up, figuring out who you are, and the highs and lows of being part of a family. Lastly, Gone Home has a way of making the story feel personal. Walking through the house, you can't shake off the feeling that you're uncovering things that are private, yet you're driven by the need to understand. There's no rush here, no score to beat or level to complete. All in all, it is one of the best mystery games like Gone Home.
Concluding our list of the best mystery games like This Bed We Made, Firewatch truly stands out. It’s a game where you step into the shoes of Henry, a man who's come to the Wyoming wilderness to get away from his troubled life. But instead of peace, he finds mystery everywhere – in the trees, in the whispers of the wind, and over the static of a walkie-talkie. Your only companion through this adventure is Delilah, your boss, who talks to you from afar. You'll find her voice a comfort and a guide as you wander the vast, open lands, with conversations that feel as real as if she were right beside you.
Also, in this game, your decisions make waves. It’s not just a game where you follow a story; you help shape it. Sometimes it feels like you're solving a puzzle, and other times it feels like you're figuring out a bit more about Henry himself. It’s all about the small details and choices that make the story feel alive. But what’s really special is how the game stays grounded. Also, there’s no magic or monsters, just the very real stories of people, and it’s these human touches that will keep you hooked.
So, what's your take on our list of these mystery games? And are there other titles that you would add to the list of must-play mystery games? Let us know your thoughts on our socials here.