10 Best Horror Games on PlayStation Plus (October 2025)

Looking to explore the most thrilling horror adventures on your console? PlayStation Plus has become a go-to platform for gamers who enjoy spooky settings, deep stories, and tense gameplay. Whether you’re into solo survival or multiplayer scares, there’s something in the collection that’ll pull you in. We’ve rounded up a solid list of horror games that are worth playing right now on PS Plus.

What Defines the Best PlayStation Plus Horror Games?

The best horror games on PlayStation Plus are the ones that deliver fear with engagement. A strong entry gives you reasons to care about every step, whether through a gripping story, unpredictable enemies, or mechanics that keep you on edge. Some rely on choice-driven narratives where survival depends on decisions, while others focus on atmosphere that never lets you feel safe. Gameplay design is also key, since limited resources, stealth, or even the absence of combat can create constant tension.

List of 10 Best Horror Games on PS Plus in 2025

These games are all packed with mystery, action, and some serious chills. Let’s jump into the list and see what’s waiting for you.

10. Dead by Daylight

First up, we have a horror game built around a deadly hunt between survivors and a killer. You step into matches with four survivors trying to escape while one killer tracks them down. Survivors must repair broken generators across the map to power exit gates, all while avoiding being caught. The killer’s job is simple – stop every escape by capturing survivors and placing them on hooks until they are eliminated. Survivors rely on stealth, smart teamwork, and quick thinking to survive, while killers focus on hunting and controlling the field. That constant chase is what keeps the action intense. Dead by Daylight earns a spot on the best horror games on PlayStation Plus list thanks to its thrilling asymmetric multiplayer design.

9. Killer Frequency

What would you expect from a horror game set inside a radio station? Playing music, chatting with callers, or running ads? Instead, you step into the role of a late-night DJ who suddenly becomes the only person able to guide townsfolk while a masked killer hunts them down. The story unfolds through phone calls, with scared voices on the line asking for help as danger closes in. Gameplay turns the studio into your main toolset – you answer calls, search through the desk, pick up notes, check equipment, and give instructions that might decide if someone survives. Every choice matters since the advice you give shapes what happens next. Killer Frequency stands out as a best PS Plus horror game because it trades guns and monsters for tense conversations.

8. Until Dawn

Until Dawn is a story-driven horror game about a group of friends trapped in a mountain lodge during dangerous events that spiral out of control. You step into the shoes of different characters, each facing life-or-death situations shaped by your decisions. Choices during dialogue, exploration, or quick reaction scenes decide who survives, with no two playthroughs ending the same. Here, gameplay is about controlling an interactive horror movie where every small action carries weight. You don’t just sit back and watch, you actively shape the story by moving through environments, picking responses, and reacting to sudden scares. Consequences unfold instantly, sometimes costing a character their life, sometimes opening new paths.

7. DREDGE

In DREDGE, you step into the role of a fisherman who arrives in a small town to earn a living at sea. The job looks simple at first, sailing a boat during the day to catch fish, sell them, and upgrade equipment for longer trips. Once night falls, the ocean changes into something far more dangerous as strange shapes move under the waves and fog hides what may attack you. Balancing daytime work with the risks of night is the heart of the game, since rare catches often mean sailing when danger is highest. Every decision to go out, head back, or push your luck carries weight, because safety and profit rarely go together. The constant cycle of fishing, upgrading, and avoiding what lurks in darkness makes it one of the best horror games on PS Plus.

6. Resident Evil 3 Nemesis

The remake of Resident Evil games we play now are cinematic, while the original entries were fixed-camera, blocky, and tense in a different way. If you want to get a taste of how the classics worked, Resident Evil 3 Nemesis is the perfect window into that era. The third entry focuses on Jill Valentine, a former police officer, trying to escape a city filled with infected people after a dangerous outbreak. What makes the game different is Nemesis, a huge bio-weapon that hunts Jill through the story. Instead of fighting regular enemies only, you also deal with this unstoppable monster that shows up again and again during the journey. Resident Evil 3 Nemesis remains a highlight in discussions about the best horror games on PlayStation Plus because of its relentless pace and iconic antagonist.

5. The Dark Pictures Anthology: House of Ashes

Following up on our list of best horror games on PlayStation Plus, House of Ashes follows soldiers trapped underground after a mission goes wrong. Strange creatures hunt them in the dark, and survival depends on how you guide the group. Control shifts between characters, letting you see how their choices connect. Each decision shapes the story, with some paths offering safety while others end in sudden death. Quick-time events test reflexes, while exploration reveals clues that deepen the mystery. The key element is how every choice stays permanent, locking you into outcomes you cannot undo.

4. Five Nights at Freddy’s: Help Wanted

The Five Nights at Freddy’s series is known for creepy animatronics that suddenly move when nobody is watching. Help Wanted continues that idea by turning past events into short jobs you must complete inside a pizzeria setting. You take the role of a worker who has to survive through different tasks that test how quick and careful you are. Each shift runs in real time while you sit in a single spot, watching security cameras and flipping between different views to track movement. Animatronics get closer with every mistake, so checking patterns and closing doors at the right moment is the only way to stay safe. Even short play sessions leave your heart racing, and it is a truly intense horror experience on PS Plus.

3. Hello Neighbor

Here, you play as a kid who suspects the neighbor is hiding something in his basement. Curiosity pushes you to sneak inside the house and uncover what he is keeping locked away. The goal is simple: get in, explore rooms, and find keys or items that help you move deeper inside. The challenge comes from the neighbor, who uses smart AI to watch how you play. If you try to use the same path twice, he blocks it with traps or patrols that spot you faster. Every attempt changes the way you must approach the house, so you need to keep trying different routes and act quickly before he catches you.

2. The Evil Within 2

The Evil Within 2 puts you in the role of Sebastian Castellanos, a detective searching for his missing daughter inside a strange digital world called STEM. The story follows his attempt to survive in a nightmare filled with creatures and hostile environments while uncovering who controls this place. This game gives freedom to move through large zones instead of fixed paths, so you choose how to handle threats. Stealth lets you hide and strike silently, while open combat allows the use of weapons and crafted items to fight directly. The balance of freedom and fear makes it worth a mention in the lineup of the best horror games on PS Plus.

1. Outlast 2

The top game on our list of best horror games on PlayStation Plus is about journalist Blake Langermann, who ends up stranded in a desert valley controlled by a violent cult. His only tool is a video camera with night vision, which becomes essential for moving through the darkness. Unlike many horror titles, combat is not an option here. Survival depends on staying hidden, running when chased, and carefully using the camera battery to avoid losing sight of threats. Outlast 2 delivers a tense experience where fear grows from powerlessness, forcing you to react under pressure and find ways to escape before it’s too late.