10 Best Horror Games on PlayStation Plus (January 2026)

Looking to explore the most thrilling horror adventures on your console? PlayStation Plus has become a go-to platform for gamers who enjoy spooky settings, deep stories, and tense gameplay. Whether you’re into solo survival or multiplayer scares, there’s something in the collection that’ll pull you in. We’ve rounded up a solid list of psychological and survival horror games that are worth playing right now on PS Plus.

What Defines the Best Horror Games?

The best horror games are the ones that deliver fear with engagement. A strong entry gives you reasons to care about every step, whether through a gripping story, unpredictable enemies, or mechanics that keep you on edge. Some rely on choice-driven narratives where survival depends on decisions, while others focus on atmosphere that never lets you feel safe. Gameplay design is also key, since limited resources, stealth, or even the absence of combat can create constant tension.

List of 10 Best Horror Games on PlayStation Plus

These games are all packed with mystery, action, and some serious chills. Let’s jump into the list and see what’s waiting for you.

10. Dead by Daylight

Online horror survival where killers hunt humans inside dark arenas

Four players run, one hunts. That’s the whole thrill. The match opens in a misty arena with scattered generators waiting to be fixed. Survivors move through silence, trying to restore power before the killer finds them. The rush of being chased by a skilled opponent makes every heartbeat matter. Then, when the killer hooks someone, the whole pace changes again. Saving a teammate means risking yourself. It’s a constant cycle of choice and panic wrapped in quick decisions.

Next, the killer side flips the experience completely. It’s about tracking, predicting, and cutting off paths. Also, every killer has a unique trick that reshapes how survivors react. Because of this, the arena never feels safe, as danger can arrive from any angle. And once a generator sparks back to life, that faint hope pushes everyone to run harder. All of this makes it one of the best multiplayer horror games on the PS Plus library.

9. Killer Frequency

Help callers survive a killer’s spree from behind the mic

Killer Frequency puts players in the shoes of a radio DJ trapped in a small-town studio. Strange calls start coming in from people being hunted by a mysterious killer. The player has to guide the callers to safety by giving quick advice based on clues found inside the station. Each call can end in success or disaster depending on how well those clues are used. The story grows darker with every call, and the pressure rises as the killer moves closer.

The game blends comedy and horror in a surprisingly smooth way. You’ll control the soundboard, move around the station, and solve small puzzles to help survivors escape. The voice acting and sound design sell the setting perfectly. In short, it’s an unusual horror experience where the danger comes through voices and choices instead of combat.

8. Dredge

Catch fish by day, face horrors by night

Dredge is a fishing adventure where players sail a small boat across quiet waters that hide strange secrets. The main goal revolves around catching fish, upgrading equipment, and exploring scattered islands to trade catches for money or clues. The loop might seem calm on the surface, yet every trip into deeper zones hints that something is off. Players manage time carefully, deciding when to venture further and when to head back before things get weird.

The ocean is full of surprises, with rare species and odd discoveries waiting to be hauled in. What begins as a regular fishing routine soon turns into a hunt for answers. Strange shapes drift beneath the waves, and odd noises echo through the night, which creates constant curiosity about what lies below. Managing your boat’s upgrades is also meaningful since it unlocks new routes and deeper mysteries. If psychological horror mixed with exploration is your thing, this one easily stands out on PS Plus Extra.

7. Until Dawn

A story-driven horror where your decisions shape who survives

Until Dawn follows a group of friends who reunite after a long time, unaware that their gathering will turn into a fight for survival. Strange events begin to unfold around them, and they soon face situations that test trust and judgment. The story explores friendship, guilt, and the weight of decisions that spiral out of control. It builds tension through conversations, discoveries, and sudden twists that constantly shift the direction of the narrative.

The gameplay runs like an interactive movie. You guide characters through narrow areas, collect clues, and make decisions during high-stakes moments. There are also sudden events where pressing the right button at the right time determines survival. At times, you must choose between saving someone or searching further for answers. These decisions shape who survives and how the mystery unfolds.

6. Still Wakes the Deep

A horror journey through an isolated oil rig in the middle of the sea

Up next on our PlayStation Plus horror games list, we have Still Wakes the Deep, a horror experience that throws you into a disaster far from normal life. You step into the shoes of a worker trapped on a collapsing oil rig where an unknown force begins to spread through the structure. The story builds around isolation and fear as communication with the outside world is cut off. The place turns into a maze of steel corridors filled with danger, noise, and panic.

The narrative keeps you grounded in human desperation and survival as hope fades and the rig sinks deeper into chaos. Gameplay flows through realistic exploration as you crawl through vents, climb wrecked platforms, and balance across damaged walkways in search of safety. Environmental puzzles, blocked paths, and sudden threats push you to think fast and adapt to every situation.

5. Hello Neighbor

A weird neighbor hides something inside his house

In Hello Neighbor, you play as someone who notices their strange neighbor doing suspicious things inside his house. The game revolves around sneaking into his home to uncover what he’s hiding in the basement. The catch is that the neighbor learns from your attempts. You look for keys, solve puzzles, and open secret doors that reveal new clues. The AI reacts to your previous moves, so you must think a bit differently with every entry. For example, if you sneak through a window, he might board it up the next time.

After spending some time in this game, you realize it’s not just about running away but understanding how everything works. You learn from mistakes, plan new routes, and test your ideas with small risks. And objects you find can be used in smart ways to solve puzzles, like stacking items to reach higher spots or opening secret passages.

4. Outlast 2

Rely on your camcorder to survive relentless chases

Outlast 2 is a first-person horror adventure that traps you in a remote area with a camera as your only tool. You’re there to investigate a mystery, but it soon turns into a fight to stay alive. The camera helps you see in the dark and record key moments, but the battery runs out fast, which forces smart use of it. There are no weapons here, so your best move is to hide, crawl, or run through the environment. The story pushes you through dark fields, tunnels, and ruined buildings filled with dangers that can appear anywhere.

Besides all that, moving through the world feels desperate and tense. Hiding inside closets or under beds gives you a short chance to breathe, yet the fear of being discovered never fades. Batteries, bandages, and clues are scattered around, waiting for careful eyes to find them. Lastly, the unpredictable encounters and limited resources keep you constantly alert. Even after years since its release, Outlast 2 remains among the best PS Plus horror games.

3. The Evil Within 2

Horror adventure that tests courage through scarce supplies and risk

The Evil Within 2 follows Detective Sebastian Castellanos as he enters a distorted world built from the mind of his missing daughter. This strange place, called STEM, connects multiple twisted realities filled with disturbing creatures and fragments of memories. The story explores guilt and obsession, blending personal struggle with a fight against impossible horrors.

What keeps it gripping is how exploration ties deeply to survival. Resources remain limited, so you must rely on careful movement and decision-making to venture further. The action unfolds through stealth, crafting, and direct combat. You can sneak behind enemies or risk open fights when escape is impossible. Exploration also matters, as side paths often reveal valuable items or hidden story details. Together, these systems create an intense horror experience.

2. The Outlast Trials

Cooperative survival game built around dangerous psychological tests

If you are searching for co-op horror games on PS Plus to play with friends, The Outlast Trials is a wild ride through fear and survival. This game was recently added to the PlayStation Plus Extra library and is part of the Outlast series, known for its nerve-shattering scares and first-person tension. It takes you into a grim Cold War setting where a secret company conducts twisted psychological experiments. You and others become unwilling subjects trapped inside a testing facility filled with deranged enemies and brutal traps.

Inside those trials, survival depends on stealth, awareness, and teamwork. You search for clues, complete tasks, and try to stay hidden from brutal test supervisors. Instead of traditional weapons, tools like bottles or bricks help distract threats for brief chances to escape. Noise can attract pursuers, so silence becomes vital. You can play with up to four players, and coordination really matters as everyone takes a role in finding paths or rescuing teammates from danger.

1. Silent Hill 2

A remake that revives a classic story of human pain

Silent Hill 2 just joined PS Plus this month, and it’s one of those horror gems no one should skip. The original version from the early 2000s became famous for its dark storytelling and emotional depth. Players loved how it explored guilt and loss through twisted creatures instead of plain scares. Its slow pace and haunting tone gave it a lasting place in horror history.

Now, the remake brings that same spirit back with modern detail and smoother flow. It follows James Sunderland as he enters the fog-covered town, searching for answers about his wife’s letter. The story still plays with the mind, offering freedom to explore through new camera angles and refined movement. You explore buildings, read notes, and piece together clues hidden in strange places. Altogether, it keeps the haunting tone alive while modernizing one of the most respected horror stories ever made.