10 Best Pirate Games Like Assassin’s Creed Black Flag Resynced

Have pirate games been as good as Assassin’s Creed Black Flag Resynced? At least not by a mile, with the piracy struggling a bit to translate to gaming. This remake makes the original so much better, with its graphical and gameplay enhancements. The Golden Age of Piracy is calling, with a fresh single-player adventure to sail the open seas and conquer untamed islands. 

It’s an open world you freely explore, where the stormy waters look and feel surreal, and the shipwrecks are potential treasure chests. For an immersive take on piracy, with a special touch of the Assassin’s Creed templars and assassins debacles, you can’t go wrong with Black Flag. And for an entirely new adventure, try out the best pirate games like Assassin’s Creed Black Flag Resynced that we’ve compiled for you.

10. Caribbean Legend

It’s a full-blown pirate life you’ll lead in Caribbean Legend, where you wake up one day and go hunting for treasure. Or romance a love interest. Hundreds of quests await you, enough to rack up hundreds of hours of playtime. It’s also thanks to the dozens of islands and cities you’re able to visit.

You only need to pick a direction and set sail, running into lots of ways to leave a mark in the Caribbean, 1654 AD. Whatever career you pick, or the people you fraternize with, is totally up to you.

9. Risen 2: Dark Waters

The pirate world in Risen 2: Dark Waters is overrun by titans who’re driving the remnant of humanity to extinction. If that weren’t enough trouble, sea monsters have rendered sailing nigh impossible. 

You guessed it, you’re the hero of this story. But you do get help from the pirates of the southern islands, who just might have the solution you need to save the world.

8. Pirates of the Caribbean: At World’s End

Among the best adaptations of Pirates of the Caribbean is Pirates of the Caribbean: At World’s End. It adapts the third film, following Jack Sparrow, Will Turner, and Elizabeth Swann’s adventures across locations from the movie and beyond. 

As to how accurate it is to the film, it doesn’t relay the scenes word for word. Instead, you enjoy a blend of familiar environments and lots of opportunities to show off your best hack-and-slash moves.

7. One Piece Odyssey

Every crew member in One Piece Odyssey’s Straw Hat crew has a role to play. It’s always about teamwork on deck, with certain crew members proficient in treasure hunting, and others repairing the ship. Around you is an open-world environment you freely explore, where you’ll meet new party members, and swap them out during combat.

6. Pillars of Eternity 2: Deadfire

Given a ship and a mission to take down a rogue god, Pillars of Eternity 2: Deadfire sets you on a path of the unknown. It’s not your typical best pirate games like Assassin’s Creed Black Flag Resynced. Running into dragons is very much a likelihood, as are mythical gods. 

Life at sea will be a tumultuous affair, with no option of turning back. At least you’ll have magic, alongside stealth and physical abilities like swimming and climbing.

5. Sid Meier’s Pirates!

You have a rough idea of the life of a pirate. But it’ll probably be much different actually living it in the 17th century. Sid Meier’s Pirates! brings its expertise with simulation to piracy, challenging you to amass riches and power from little resources. 

It’s up to you how you become the most powerful pirate, whether you sail and plunder to your heart’s content or chase fame. You’ll enjoy lots of ways to level up, with plenty of gameplay around naval combat, treasure hunting, trade, and even romance.

4. LEGO Pirates of the Caribbean: The Video Game

LEGOs go with just about every franchise, this time, piracy. As the fourth-ranking addition to the best pirate games like Assassin’s Creed Black Flag Resynced, it does a pretty good job of merging the lighthearted art style and humor of LEGO with the authentic adaptation of the Pirates of the Caribbean four films.

At this point, I’ve rewatched the films so many times, it’s awesome to revisit the highlights in LEGO Pirates of the Caribbean: The Video Game. While not accurate scene-for-scene, it still remains true to the main plotlines.

3. Monkey Island Series

As many as six main games have been released in the Monkey Island series. To start with, this is a point-and-click adventure series featuring a charming cartoon-inspired pixel art style. You’ll laugh your heart out adventuring the Caribbean Islands as the naive Guybrush Threepwood. 

It’s a struggle for him to become the most notorious pirate in the region, with rival undead pirate LeChuck posing a threat to his ascension. That, and other gamified quests to discover tucked-away secrets and rescue Governor Elaine Marley from LeChuck.

2. Like a Dragon: Pirate Yakuza in Hawaii

When you’re told to design your own pirate game, you probably won’t come up with Like a Dragon: Pirate Yakuza in Hawaii. And that’s the beauty of this one, how experimental it is, with the franchise typically based in the criminal underworld of Tokyo.

Instead, series’ fan-favorite Goro Majima takes a vacation to tropical Hawaii. As part of your playthrough, you find yourself in Madlantis, which is a pirate island that plays by no rules. You can explore the seas here, but be wary of intense battles against rival pirates and the island’s aggressive mobs.

1. Sea of Thieves

Few found Sea of Thieves less than subpar. Its content is packed with the fully-lived life of a pirate. Hunting treasure, battling rival crews, and even sea monsters to boot. It’s all neatly packaged in an adventure you’ll want your friends to tag along. 

It dutifully combines exploration and looting to great effect, where your ambition to cover treaherous ground raises your ranks among your crew. A massive open world awaits. Will you be the first to claim its bountiful underwater kingdoms and uncharted islands?