10 Best Games Like Mixtape 2026

What I’d give to go back in time and relive the carefree days of being a teenager. The mischief I’d get into with my pals remains some of the best memories I have. Now imagine if you could pick one memory and travel back in time. You’d arrive at the precise location where you formed the memory, and your friends will be with you, ready to reenact your best moments. 

Mixtape has been a godsend for swimming in nostalgia. All you do is scroll to pick your next adventure. And the music and visuals comply, dashed in heartwarming ‘90s graphics. You skate with your friends, relive your first kiss, and watch the fireworks go off from the back of your car. A sweet compilation that leaves you with bittersweet feelings of how much we’ve grown. 

It’s no surprise that Mixtape has earned perfect scores from most video game critics, with our own Jord Tury awarding it a 10/10 in his review, calling it “a portal in which you, the collector of memories and adolescent sagas, are given exclusive access to a seemingly perfect timeline that’s both intimate and incredibly nostalgic.” 

It’s an adventure that ends too soon. But fortunately for you, we’ve rounded up the best games like Mixtape, so the adventure never ends.

10. Before Your Eyes

They say your whole life flashes Before Your Eyes just before you die. Some of your best and worst memories stream through your mind in rapid succession. There are lots of things, I imagine, that you might still need to reconcile, and that’s the focus of this game.

To help you pass on, a mystical Ferryman must send you back to relive your most significant moments in life. You’re in full control over how your life unfolds, using an innovative “blinking” mechanic to move from the story of your first love to your career as an artist and memories with family.

9. Road 96

There’s that one road trip that changed your life. That’s Road 96’s focal point. It’s charming but also filled with the unexpected. You pass through unforgettable places and meet the most eccentric people. 

But this is also a journey of self-discovery. It’s a challenge about finding freedom on the open roads, with the themes of authoritarian rule and oppression. 

8. What Remains of Edith Finch

What Remains of Edith Finch lets you step out of your own shoes into the family of Edith Finch. It’s a mystical story that casts you into the life of each family member, reliving the days leading up to their death. 

Get ready to unearth strange events surrounding Edith’s family and their life at the majestic Finch house. You’ll grapple with the vast world around Edith’s family and the unending questions of the unknown.

7. OPUS: Prism Peak

The best way to document memories has forever been through snapshots. And OPUS: Prism Peak uses photography to an intense emotional effect. It represents your view of the world, and how you help your traveling companion who’s lost her memories understand her surroundings. 

But you’re also trying to find your home. And hence, a compelling entanglement of mystery and careful observation. Within your captured photos are the answers you seek.

6. Firewatch

You’ll be well pleased with Firewatch, the next entry among the best games like Mixtape. It casts you into the role of a fire watcher, wandering the Wyoming wilderness to watch out for any smoke and potential fire. 

It’s a lonely job on a hot, dry summer, and the only company is a voice on the radio. Soon, the story builds into a compelling mystery, having you make tough choices whose impact could destroy your only friendship.

5. Wanderstop

Wanderstop reminds me of those seemingly insignificant moments in life that end up changing your whole perspective on things you’ve been struggling with. A veteran fighter is forced to serve tea at a small tea shop. 

Despite her initial reservations about how insignificant the role is, it turns out to be the lifeline she needs to find herself and redefine her identity.

4. People of Note

A huge part of Mixtape’s charm is the music, delightful throughout its run-through. To maintain the same momentum, you can check out the rhythm-based RPG musical, People of Note. While you’re rounding up your new band, in preparation for the Noteworthy Song Contest, you run into all sorts of enemies you battle against through music. 

Battles unravel via musical performances, with your attacks syncing to the beat of the music, and genres blending to create more powerful combos.

3. Lake

Returning to the home you grew up in always brings overwhelming emotions of the past to the surface. In the next entry in the best games like Mixtape, you help 40-something-year-old Meredith face her past. 

Lake shows the deep contrast moving from a busy city life to a small town, where you take on a new role of delivering mail. You have two weeks in Providence Oaks, Oregon. But those two weeks are enough to leave a lasting impact. They may even be enough to convince you to stay longer.

2. Life is Strange

Life is Strange has six games so far. While not all of them are on the same caliber of emotional depth, the story of Max and Chloe continues to be among the best friendship/romances in gaming. 

And the latest Reunion gives the two lovebirds the send-off they deserve. But even with the emotional highs and lows, there are mysteries to solve, and fun time-manipulating abilities to engage you throughout the series’ interactive drama adventure.

From strong writing fleshing out relatable personalities to tough life-or-death decisions you have to make, Life is Strange hits all the right spots for a delightful game like Mixtape.

1. Lost Records: Blook & Rage

First in our list of the best games like Mixtape is Lost Records: Block & Rage. Four high school girls once close in the ‘90s decide to go their separate ways, not out of choice, but because of a mystical event they tried to bury. But most secrets you try to bury end up coming to light, and you’re forced to confront a past you thought was long gone.

Lost Records: Block & Rage is a powerful mix of warm nostalgia and dread. It pulls you into the life of teenagers trying to figure out what really happened decades ago, and in the process, confronting hard truths about their friendship.