Licenses
EU Court’s Fourth Chamber Declares Malta Gaming Referral Inadmissible

Key PointsThe EU Court's Fourth Chamber dismissed Austria's referral without ruling on Malta's…
View more
- The EU Court's Fourth Chamber dismissed Austria's referral without ruling on Malta's Article 56A gaming provision.
- The Vienna court must now judge whether the July 2023 opinion was defensible when given.
- Spielerschutz Sigma sued its adviser after Malta's First Hall of the Civil Court rejected enforcement.
The Fourth Chamber of the Court of Justice of the European Union on November 19, 2026 declared inadmissible an Austrian court’s request for guidance on Malta’s gaming legislation, ruling that answers about the recognition and enforcement of player-loss judgments were unnecessary to resolve a damages claim against a litigation funder’s legal adviser.
The judgment disposed of the reference without deciding whether Article 56A of Malta’s Gaming Act complies with EU law. Malta inserted the provision on June 12, 2023, prohibiting actions against Maltese-licensed gaming operators as contrary to public policy and requiring its courts to refuse recognition or enforcement of foreign judgments arising from those actions.
Why the Court Declined to Answer
The preliminary-ruling procedure supplies national courts with interpretations needed to decide disputes; requests seeking advisory opinions on general or hypothetical questions are inadmissible. The Court said the required connection must be “real and concrete,” rather than “purely hypothetical, theoretical or simply speculative.”
The Vienna damages action is governed by Austrian expert-liability rules, which also apply to lawyers. Under those rules, an incorrect assessment produces liability for resulting damage only with fault, while an incorrect legal interpretation can remain defensible if it was consistent with at least some case law or legal doctrine existing when the opinion was provided. Whether authorities or courts later apply that interpretation is not decisive.
The Court therefore found that the parties’ performance of their legal-consultation obligations was independent of Article 56A’s compatibility with EU law. A preliminary ruling delivered after the opinion would not establish whether the advice was reasonably defensible under the legal framework and information available when it was provided.
Litigation Behind the Reference
Spielerschutz Sigma Prozessfinanzierungs GmbH, a Vienna-based litigation funder, finances claims by Austrian online gambling players against operators holding Maltese licences whose services are accessible in Austria without a valid Austrian licence. The referring court said players can seek reimbursement of losses under national unjust-enrichment and civil-liability provisions, and the funder had obtained numerous reimbursement judgments through its clients that it sought to enforce in Malta.
After Malta’s amendment, the company asked its legal adviser to assess the provision’s compatibility with EU law and the possibility of Maltese courts applying it. The July 5, 2023 opinion concluded that Article 56A was clearly contrary to EU law, that its application in Maltese enforcement proceedings was inconceivable, and that first-instance enforcement proceedings would finish within six months.
On July 19, 2023, Malta’s First Hall of the Civil Court rejected a recognition and enforcement request in proceedings funded by Spielerschutz Sigma, specifically invoking Article 56A; the company was notified on August 1, 2023. The referring court also said Maltese courts had rejected other recognition and enforcement requests under the provision, and no Maltese decision had questioned its validity or EU-law compatibility.
The funder responded by suing the adviser in Vienna for repayment of the €5,000 opinion fee and a declaration that the adviser would be liable for future damage connected with proceedings funded between delivery of the opinion and notification of the Maltese rejection. The adviser maintained that its conclusions were correct and that it had reasonably expected Maltese courts to follow EU law and its primacy.
The Referred Questions
After staying the damages case, the Vienna Commercial Court made its request on October 16, 2024. Its five questions concerned Regulation No 1215/2012, the EU framework governing jurisdiction and the recognition and enforcement of civil and commercial judgments. They included whether public policy could justify Malta’s refusal mechanism and whether an unexplained first-instance delay beyond six months would breach the regulation’s obligation to decide without delay. Germany and Malta argued that the answers were unnecessary to decide the damages case.
Malta separately asked on May 8, 2026 for the oral part of the procedure to be reopened if the reference were admissible, invoking the right to an effective remedy in the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights. The Court refused, finding that it had sufficient information, Malta had supplied no decisive new fact, and the Charter does not impose an absolute requirement for a public hearing in every case.
The Court left costs between the parties to the Vienna court. Its decision returns the dispute to the Austrian liability test: whether the July 2023 opinion was defensible on the legal framework and information available at the time, rather than whether the adviser’s prediction about Maltese enforcement proved correct.













