10 Best Games Like The Sinking City 2 2026

The Sinking City 2 is a survival horror game set in a Lovecraftian 1920s Arkham world. Everything is about to be buried in flooding water, a supernatural, persistent rainfall that seawalls you inside the city. A fish market, drowned speakeasies, and abandoned parlors all harbor secrets you unearth through solving unnerving detective puzzles and fighting back eldritch horrors. It’s a curious game, amid fear and terrifying supernatural forces that you keep pushing through until you’ve found a way out. And if you care for a similar experience, well, the best games like The Sinking City 2 should give you a tasteful balance of survival, horror, detective work, and all in-between.

10. Still Wakes the Deep

It’s 1975. You’re trapped on an oil rig, somewhere off the coast of Scotland. Your ship is crashing down from storms and relentless waves. But perhaps worse is the otherworldly horror beyond what the mind can comprehend. Still Wakes the Deep kicks us off with a first-person horror experience that will scare the living nightmare out of you.

It comes from the creators of Amnesia, playing tricks on your mind from the panic of never seeing your family again. It’s deeply immersive from the inside of the ship to the roaring sea. You won’t have much combat skills to lean on, just survival through wit and a persistent will to live.

9. Resident Evil Requiem

I had to include the star of survival horror, the standard, which I compare how terrifying The Sinking City 2 ends up being. FBI Analyst and rookie, Grace Ashcroft, stars in Resident Evil Requiem, alongside fan-favorite agent, Leon Kennedy. You’ll play the game from both their perspective, switching from a terrified and inexperienced analyst to the skilled and badass Leon. These give you a good balance between survival horror and combat. The anxiety that comes with not knowing how to handle a gun to the adrenaline spike when you swap between headshots and shredding enemies with your chainsaw.

8. Bloodborne

It’s interesting how some of the best games like The Sinking City 2 create their own Lovecraftian-inspired universe. Games like Bloodborne, which do a fantastic job acquainting you with its plague-infested dark fantasy world. The Yharnam city where the game is set also has gothic architecture and a Victorian-era aesthetic. But it’s also overrun by monsters, disease and death.

7. Amnesia

And then you have the Amnesia games, which are some of the best nerve-racking games. Pick your poison, out of the four games, and the DLC, incorporating puzzles, exploration, and survival horror. Psychological horror, more precisely, when you wake up not knowing who you are, and must make sense of things through exploring terrifying levels, and piecing together clues. But you also avoid monsters, reaching a point when the monster turns out to have been within.

6. Call of Cthulhu

The role-playing survival horror game, Call of Cthulhu, is set in 1924. It follows a P.I., investigating the mysterious death of the Hawkins family. It’s an otherworldly mystery that will transport you to a Lovecraftian world of terror and madness. Where Darkwater Island harbors strange creatures and sinister cults. In the shadows are lurking figures that push your sanity to the brink.

5. The Forgotten City

If you’re big on exciting stories, then The Forgotten City may better tend to your needs. It’s a time-traveling tale set in ancient Rome, exploring an underground city from 2000 years past. You search for answers about the city’s collapse, facing life and death choices, discovering historic architecture and costumes, and advancing a mystery-ridden story with multiple endings.

4. The Shore

Also based on Lovecraftian horror is The Shore. Your daughter is lost at sea, and you have to get past ocean monsters to rescue her. There are puzzles to solve, and secrets to unravel. While the environments, by the shore, underwater, and far out into the endless sea, are breathtaking, the atmosphere also hangs with dread. And when the monsters leap out of the shadows, the momentum spikes, given that you have access to ancient god-like powers to deal with enemies head-on.

3. Sherlock Holmes

There are a couple of Sherlock Holmes games that should quench your thirst for the detective work in The Sinking City 2. Chapter One is a detective thriller about Sherlock heading out to an exotic island to investigate his mother’s death. You might enjoy The Awakened, which now incorporates Lovecraftian horror, as well as mysterious cases to solve across Europe and the US. The Devil’s Daughter is a great choice, too, for the best games like The Sinking City 2, given its prime focus on searching for clues and interrogating suspects all across the darkest corners of London.

2. Dredge

A fishing adventure might seem odd to include here, but Dredge has some intriguing dark mystery hiding behind its deceptively calm art style. You have a boat, fishing tools, and a village to buy and sell from. But every day at sea brings its own challenges, and the deeper you drift away from civilization, the more dangerous it gets. Long-buried secrets begin to cloud over your fishing expeditions, as you stumble onto a dark mystery bigger than yourself. And yet, you can’t help it, sailing farther and farther out until you make sense of the eldritch Lovecraftian horror at the heart and soul of this game’s remote isles.

1. The Sinking City

Fortunately, you have The Sinking City Remastered to enjoy an enhanced gaming experience of the first go at the flooding city. 1920s Oakmont is crashing under the weight of the horror and oppression of nightmarish monsters. As a private investigator, you face the danger head-on at the expense of your sanity. Combining exploration and detective work, The Sinking City fills your gaming sessions with curiosity and intrigue. It gives you a decent weapon base and creates an investigation system where you can track down several cases and arrive at different solutions depending on the choices you make.