라이선스
Kalshi’s New York Gambling Case Moves Back to State Court

핵심 포인트브로더릭 판사는 연방 관할권이 없다는 이유로 칼시에 대한 뉴욕주의 도박 단속 소송을 주 법원으로 환송했다.
더 보기
- 브로더릭 판사는 연방 관할권이 없다는 이유로 칼시에 대한 뉴욕주의 도박 단속 소송을 주 법원으로 환송했다.
- 지정 계약 시장으로서 칼시의 CFTC 지정은 연방 이송 관할권의 근거가 아니라 방어 수단이다.
- 브로더릭은 칼시의 이송 주장이 표면상 성립하고 객관적으로 합리적이었기 때문에 뉴욕주 변호사 비용을 기각했다.
U.S. District Judge Vernon S. Broderick on 2026년 11월 19일, granted New York Attorney General Letitia James’s request to return the state’s enforcement action against prediction-market operator KalshiEX LLC to state court, finding no federal subject-matter jurisdiction and directing immediate remand to the Supreme Court of New York, New York County.
The ruling determines the forum, not whether Kalshi’s event contracts violate New York gambling laws. Because Broderick found no jurisdiction, he said he could not decide Kalshi’s request to stop the attorney general from using an investigative subpoena to obtain evidence about the claims.
What New York Alleges
Kalshi operates an exchange offering yes-or-no event contracts on subjects including elections, reality competitions and sporting events. New York seeks to permanently stop Kalshi from operating what the state says is an unlicensed gambling business and to bar the company, its principals, agents and employees from violating the state constitution and laws.
New York brings eight claims under a state law authorizing the attorney general to seek injunctions over repeated or persistent fraudulent or illegal acts. One claim is based on the state constitution, three on penal law, three on racing law and one on the federal Wire Act.
New York requires businesses offering mobile sports wagering to hold a Gaming Commission license, prohibits sports wagering by people under 21 and bars sports wagering on events involving New York college teams. The state alleges that Kalshi lacks a commission license, allows users aged 18 through 20 and offers contracts on events involving those teams.
The Gaming Commission issued Kalshi a cease-and-desist on 2025년 10월 24일, over its allegedly unlicensed mobile sports-wagering platform. In a separate federal case, Judge Analisa Torres denied Kalshi’s motion for a preliminary injunction against enforcement of New York gambling laws on 2026년 7월 7일.
Why Federal Jurisdiction Failed
New York filed the action in state court on 2026년 7월 31일, and Kalshi removed it to federal court the same day. The state moved for remand on 2026년 8월 7일. Kalshi relied on its 2020년 11월 3일, certification by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) as a designated contract market, a status subjecting it to federal derivatives regulation. It argued that its federal license amounted to intangible property derived from a federal officer and that New York’s case affected the validity of the Commodity Exchange Act.
Broderick found that New York was not challenging the act’s legal force, seeking to invalidate any of its provisions or asking for Kalshi’s federal status to be revoked. Kalshi’s reliance on federal authorization was a defense to the allegations, and a federal defense cannot supply removal jurisdiction. The argument that the CFTC was a necessary party also failed because Kalshi provided no authority that failing to join a necessary federal agency, by itself, creates removal jurisdiction.
Broderick also rejected the federal-question argument. The claims based on state law did not necessarily raise federal issues because their predicates contain no exception for conduct authorized by the Commodity Exchange Act and do not incorporate federal definitions. The Wire Act claim did necessarily raise an actually disputed issue: whether Kalshi’s contracts are bets or wagers under a federal law prohibiting the interstate transmission of bets or wagers.
Broderick nevertheless found that issue insufficiently substantial for federal jurisdiction. The proposed path from the Wire Act to the Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act and then to exclusive CFTC jurisdiction over swaps failed because the internet-gambling statute expressly says it does not alter, limit or extend other federal or state gambling laws.
Broderick separately concluded that federal adjudication would disrupt the federal-state balance. Gambling regulation is predominantly a state concern, and the Commodity Exchange Act leaves room for other regulatory authorities. Keeping the case in federal court would also displace New York’s chosen forum and the procedural mechanisms available to seek expedited relief through the state’s special proceeding.
Despite granting remand, Broderick denied New York’s request for attorneys’ fees and costs because he could not conclude that Kalshi lacked an objectively reasonable basis for removal. He described the company’s arguments as colorable, noted that another federal court had accepted a related argument and found no unusual circumstances supporting an award.
New York’s injunction request therefore proceeds in the state forum it selected, while Kalshi’s appeal of Judge Torres’s separate ruling remains pending as a federal challenge to enforcement.













